Fri, Mar 7, 2008 3:51pm ET

Send to a friend Print Version

Discussing Clinton's tax returns, MSNBC's Buchanan did not note that McCain has not released his returns

Summary: On MSNBC, while saying that Sen. Hillary Clinton should release her tax returns, Pat Buchanan asserted, "[L]ook, there's an awful lot of money that those two made, and they want to see where the money came from, especially where Bill's income came from if they filed a joint return," adding, "And I think Republicans will demand it." However, Buchanan did not note that Sen. John McCain also has not released his tax returns.

On the March 7 edition of MSNBC's Morning Joe, while saying that Sen. Hillary Clinton should release her tax returns, MSNBC contributor and guest host Pat Buchanan asserted, "[L]ook, there's an awful lot of money that those two made, and they want to see where the money came from, especially where Bill's income came from if they filed a joint return," adding, "And I think Republicans will demand it." However, Buchanan did not note, as several in the media have reported, that Sen. John McCain so far has not released his tax returns. For example, The Wall Street Journal reported on February 23: "The presumptive Republican nominee, Arizona Sen. John McCain, hasn't released his tax returns either. His campaign has said it won't decide whether to release the returns until after he is officially the nominee." Primary victories March 4 gave McCain "a total of 1,205 delegates, 14 more than the 1,191 required to secure the Republican nomination."

From the March 7 edition of MSNBC's Morning Joe:

MIKA BRZEZINSKI (co-host): OK, Pat Buchanan, I guess my question to you is, I feel -- I don't know if I'm the only one who feels this way, but I feel like the real difference between these candidates is Hillary Clinton's legacy in the White House with her husband, and all these other potential mysteries and questions that could be dredged up, like, Ken Starr-related, and whether voters want to go back there or not. And Barack Obama's newness, freshness, but perhaps a big question mark. Why would he do that?

BUCHANAN: Well, that is -- I mean -- I don't know why [Clinton spokesman Howard] Wolfson did that. I mean, as I understand it, all Barack did, said, "Why doesn't Hillary release her tax returns?" And if -- you're getting a little bit sensitive when you start comparing that to a Ken Starr attack. But Mika, you are really --

BRZEZINSKI: Yeah. I mean, is there something wrong with those returns?

BUCHANAN: If there -- I don't know. My guess is they -- look, there's an awful lot of money that those two made, and they want to see where the money came from, especially where Bill's income came from if they filed a joint return.

BRZEZINSKI: Right.

BUCHANAN: And I think the Republicans will demand it.

But Mika, you're exactly right. Look, this is Hillary's problem. What problems you mentioned are exactly her problem.

—M.B.B.

Comments (37) - Join the Discussion
Please upgrade your flash player! The video for this item requires a newer version of Flash Player. If you are unable to install flash you can download a QuickTime version of the video.

Embed this video:

Trouble viewing clip? Download: QuickTime

 
Take Action!

Contact information:

MSNBC
Mr. Phil Griffin,
Senior Vice President, News
NBC Television Network
30 Rockefeller Plz
New York, NY 10112
phil.griffin@nbc.com

Steve Capus,
President, NBC News
steve.capus@nbc.com

MSNBC
letters@msnbc.com
MSNBC/Microsoft-NBC
30 Rockefeller Plz
3rd Fl
New York, NY 10112
(212) 664-4444

When contacting the media, please be polite and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and be sure to indicate exactly what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.

Issues / Media Tags Help
Issue:
Government and Elections
Sub-Issue:
2008 Elections
Topics:
Hillary Clinton
John McCain
Person:
Pat Buchanan
Show/Publication:
Morning Joe
Network/Outlet:
MSNBC
Personalized Alerts
Show Your Support
County Fair
Radioactive
Media Matters Action Center - Make a Difference!
RSS Feeds

Media Matters uses a taxonomy structure to help readers find information on various subjects. You can view all items by issue (the broadest category), view an issue's subissue, and even drill down to a particular topic. You can also look at items according to the related media personality, show/publication and network/publisher.

Social bookmarking sites allow you to save links to interesting items and share them with other users. Some, like Digg.com, also allow you to discuss these items and promote them to wider audiences by "digging" the ones that you like. To start using these services, simply register with the site in question.